The Rosary Light & Life - Vol 60, No 2, March-April 2007

Theology for the Laity

The Creed, Part V
He Descended Into Hell and On The Third Day He Rose Again

By Father Reginald Martin, O.P.

       Anyone who compares the Apostlesí Creed to the Nicene Creed will notice a significant difference. The Apostlesí Creed takes note of Our Saviorís descent into hell. Faithful Christians are often puzzled by this and ask why Christ descended into hell, and whether this is the same hell to which mortal sin condemns the sinner who dies without repentance.

       St. Thomas does not provide answers to these questions in the Lenten homilies we have been studying. However, he considers the questions at some length in his Summa Theologica. He says that Christ did not descend into the "hell of the lost." Rather, "...upon the holy Fathers detained in hell solely on account of original sin, He shed the light of glory everlasting" (ST III. 52.2).

Two Hells?

       St. Thomas distinguishes between the "hell of the lost" and the "hell of the patriarchs." The former is the state of those who have died unrepentant for mortal sin; the latter is the state of the righteous individuals under the Old Law who died, necessarily, without seeing their Savior.

Two Visits?

       To say that Christ descended into hell does not mean that He paid an equal visit to all the individuals languishing there. Those condemned to eternal punishment would have received no benefit from Christís presence among them. However, the souls of the damned were well aware of Christís descent. St. Thomas tells us, " descending thither, He put them to shame for their unbelief and wickedness" (ST III. 52.2).

       If this seems confusing, St. Thomas teaches us by way of an example.

The Lesson of Christís Descent

       The Angelic Doctor preached that the first lesson we should carry away from Christ's descent among the souls of the dead is one of hope. Although St. Thomas bases his argument for hope on Scripture, it also appeals to our common sense. The book of Ecclesiaticus says, "he that feareth the Lord shall tremble at nothing; he shall not be afraid, for He is his hope" (Ecclus 34:16). St. Thomas remarks we can suffer nothing worse than to be in hell. "So if Christ freed those who were in hell, anyone - provided he is a friend of God - should be confident that God will deliver him from his straits whatever they are."

A Remedy for Fear and Presumption

       St. Thomas reminds us that Jesus did not deliver every soul from hell, only the souls of the righteous. Thus, he urges us to reflect on our lives, and to conclude that if we strive to remain in the state of grace we have no reason to doubt Godís mercy. On the other hand, we should also consider the souls Christ left to their punishment, and not assume that God will overlook our sins if we fail to repent.

A Daily Consideration

       The author of the Books of the Maccabees commands us, "remember thy last end, and thou shalt never sin" (2 Mac 12.46). Jesus descended into hell for our salvation and instruction, so St. Thomas urges us to follow Him there, considering the punishments our sins deserve. He continues this admonition by saying that those who make a spiritual descent into hell in life are not apt to make the descent in death.

An Example from Life

       We express perfect contrition when we grieve because our sins have offended Godís goodness. However, the Church teaches that imperfect contrition - i.e., sorrow because we fear the punishment due to sin - is sufficient for our salvation. St. Thomas reminds us that we avoid breaking civil laws because we reasonably fear the punishment that will follow if we are found guilty. If the punishment of hell exceeds the penalty for breaking any law on earth, how much more, St. Thomas asks, should we fear to break Godís law?

An Example of Love

       Christ continually calls us to follow Him, and His descent into hell is a particularly effective example. Christís visit to the netherworld to deliver the just "from their privation of glory" (ST III 52.8, reply 3), invites us to remember the souls in Purgatory. The Scripture teaches "it is a holy and wholesome thought to pray for the dead that they be loosed from sins" (2 Macc 12:46), and the Church fathers identify Masses, prayers, almsgiving and fasting as effective sacrifices to offer for the salvation of those who have died in a state of venial sin.

       Once again St. Thomas draws an example from our daily life, reminding us that only a very cruel person would fail to offer help to a friend in prison. If we are willing to pay a debt for a friend in this world, how much more eagerly - considering the far greater punishment a soul suffers in Purgatory - should we come to the aid of those who have died?

Christís Resurrection and Ours

       When discussing the knowledge necessary for our salvation, St. Thomas is very succinct. "Man must know two things: the glory of God and the punishments of hell." These realities were hard to grasp in the ages before Christís example-filled life, death and resurrection, but they are considerably easier for us to understand now.

       Godís Word took on our flesh so that we, who had forfeited, through sin, our glory as Godís children could learn a lesson from Godís only Son. Likewise, although the pains of sin might have been hard to discern at one time, they are considerably easier to comprehend now that Christ has visited hell and returned to tell us what awaits the souls of the unrepentant.

What the Resurrection Teaches

       The title by which Jesus is most often addressed in the gospel is "teacher," and the early Church writers said Christ came to save us by His example, going through every moment of our lives - from the first to the last - and teaching us how to face the many challenges of our human existence. The Resurrection completes this education, enabling Our Savior to show us in His risen body what we have to look forward to if we remain faithful to His commands, and what we will face if we ignore them.

Call to Faith

       The Resurrection confirms our faith and encourages us to hope. In the Old Testament Job cried out, "I know that my Redeemer liveth, and therefore in the last day I shall rise out of the earth... this [is] my hope...." In the Resurrection, God allows us to see what Job and the other righteous patriarchs could only imagine.

A Call to Virtue

       St. Paul teaches, "As Christ is risen from the dead... so we also may walk in newness of life" (Rom 6.4). The Resurrection reminds us that death is not the final reality for a Christian, and one of the prefaces for the funeral Mass proclaims, "Lord, for your faithful people life is changed [in death], not ended." The promise of resurrection invites us to live in the present, but with an eye on the future. Christís Resurrection reveals the glory we are called to share, and encourages us to live in a manner worthy of that great hope.

Christís Unique Resurrection

       The Old Testament relates the resurrection of one or two individuals, and the gospel tells us Jesus raised a young woman and two men (including Lazarus) after they had died. God undoubtedly intends to inspire us by these examples, but we must not forget that the Resurrection of Our Savior differs from all the rest. Each of the individuals called back to life in the Scripture died from illness or weakness, and all were restored to life by the power of God; none of these rose by his own power.

       Jesus, on the other hand, died by His own choice, and rose by His own power. His divinity was never separated from His humanity, so He could truly claim, "I have power to lay down my life and I have power to take it up again" (John 10.18). When we profess our faith we say, "He rose again," and these words remind us that the Resurrection was the result of Jesusí own activity, not the effect of someone else acting on the Saviorís behalf.

Resurrection to a Perfect Life

       Christís Resurrection differs from the resurrection of those He restored to life because Lazarus and the others resumed the same life they had enjoyed before, a life that included the necessity of dying once again. Christís Resurrection is not only deliverance from death, but deliverance from the possibility of dying. Thus, Christís perfect Resurrection establishes the pattern which the other resurrections looked forward to, although imperfectly. Resurrection in Time

       Finally, Jesusí Resurrection differs from the resurrection we anticipate because His Resurrection took place "on the third day," while the rest of humanity (except the Blessed Virgin) awaits resurrection at the end of time. In his homily on the Resurrection St. Thomas says the Resurrection occurred as it did because Christ took on our flesh, died and rose "for our salvation."

       When he quotes these words from the Creed, St. Thomas explains that the Resurrection, no less than every other event in Our Saviorís life, was aptly calculated, to give us the greatest possible advantage. Had Jesus risen before the third day the world might not have believed He truly died; had he delayed His Resurrection, the disciples might have lost heart and failed to carry out the preaching task the Savior entrusted to them.

We Learn from the Resurrection
St. Thomas preached that the first example the Resurrection teaches is the necessity to rise spiritually from the death of sin. Each Act of Contrition, each visit to the Sacrament of Reconciliation, each time we receive the Eucharist we experience a personal Resurrection that brings us closer to Christ, and allows us to participate more fully in the life He won for us.

The Lesson of the Third Day

       Our Savior did not delay His Resurrection unnecessarily; neither should we. The Church sings a Lenten response that reminds us, "in the midst of life we are in death." Medical advances and a greater awareness of the importance of healthful living have unquestionably increased the lifespan of those who live in the developed countries of the world. Nevertheless, St. Thomas reminds us,

       The Venerable Bede adds that the longer we put off repentance, and the longer the devil possesses us, the more loathe he is to lose his hold on us. We may delay death, and prolong life, but common sense suggests we should use the time we have gained in following - not shirking - the example of the Lord.

Incorruptible Life

       Once we have surrendered to Christís reconciling love, we should strive to live fully the new life we have received, by avoiding the death of sin. St. Paul reminds us, "Christ rising from the death dieth now no moreÖ so do you also reckon that you are dead to sin but alive unto God, in Christ Jesus" (Rom 6:9).

       The virtue of hope enables us to live in this world "as if" we already enjoyed the blessings we look forward to in heaven. In Godís kingdom of heaven we will enjoy fully what we can only anticipate on earth: a life that will neither end nor be diminished by weakness, illness or sin. We cannot avoid these evils on earth, but the Christianís life of prayer, and the Sacraments that unite us to Christís saving death and resurrection, cultivate a contemplative spirit, and this enables us to grasp as fully as possible in this life the joys we look forward to possessing in the next.

Mary and the Resurrection

       The Resurrection is a mystery, and therefore we may be slow to grasp its effect on our everyday lives. After all, Jesus was divine; why should He not have risen from the dead? None of us can claim the unique perfection of Jesus, so why should we expect deliverance from death and decay.

       Christ invites us to share His supreme goodness, but the sheer immensity of that goodness may be so overwhelming that we are reluctant to approach Our Savior, simply because we feel so unworthy of His love. In this dilemma, the example of the Mother of God offers us counsel and hope.

       Sin claims no part in the nature of the Son of God, so our faith (reasonably) teaches that the human Jesus was like us in all things but sin. This is not the case with the Virgin Mary. She was like us in all things, including our need to be delivered from sin, and our faith teaches that Godís gift of Baptism after our birth echoes the special gift God gave Mary before she was born.

Christ Sets the Pattern; Mary Shows the Way

       Christís Resurrection shows us what we can look forward to. Maryís Assumption demonstrates that the everlasting life of heaven is, indeed, a promise we can trust. Mary embodies all the virtuous hope of Godís people in the Old Testament, and her Magnificat is a triumphant sermon on Godís mercy: "He has put down the mighty from their thrones, and exalted those of low degree" (Lk 1.52). Maryís Assumption fulfills these words, and extends a powerful invitation to follow her example of humility.

Back to Light & Life Page | Way Back to Rosary Center Home Page